A New Theology of Dating: I am not just your “brother.”
I’ve met a number of Christian men and women whose dating theology is:
God is idealistic about love, and we should be too.
These Christians typically come from conservative churches where men and women are not friends (and sometimes prohibited from interacting). They read Josh Harris and Elisabeth Elliot, not realizing that those books are at best aimed for teenagers.
The problem with any strict idealism is that it doesn’t account for messy reality. In the case of dating, idealism means there are two categories of male-female relationships:
A: brother and sister (strictly platonic)
B: on the path to holy matrimony
This system represses girls. They are taught not to flirt. Because that would just cause guys in camp A to stumble, and there’s no need to flirt to attract the type-B guy. When he knows, he’ll know. And girls have to turn down dates with any guys who don’t fit her idea of who she’ll marry.
This system emasculates guys. Since girls don’t flirt with them, guys get no positive encouragement about their own sexual desirability. And since asking out is such a serious matter (a date means you’re on path B and better think about how many kids you want), guys can’t ask out girls until they are sure enough. And girls can’t say yes until they’re sure enough.
Result: low self-esteem, very few couples, sparse or absent male-female friendships, and anemic spiritual growth in the area of handling romantic relationships.
It’s hard for me to believe this is what God intended for men and women.
It’s true that God is idealistic. But he doesn’t express that idealism by neatly categorizing into A and B. Instead, he expresses it through a real Christ who came to live and die among us, despite our messiness, our smells, our sins. He had messy relationships too, although any romantic ones weren’t documented.
Here is my plea. Men and women should be friends, and sometimes more, and sometimes less. People can’t be neatly categorized — why should relationships? Messiness is a part of life. Certainly at various points, things need to be clarified and commitments made. But before then, I’m in favor of flirting and affirming each others’ desirability. And having ambiguous relationships that evolve and leave room for hope, faith, grace, open communication, mistakes, and forgiveness.
Unfortunately, many Christians will choose to stay in their idealistic fairy-tale land. So the princess lies asleep in the guarded castle, waiting for her prince to come set her free. And occasionally this happens, because the men who live in fairy-tale land don their armor (the breastplate of righteousness, etc…) and sally forth. Some of these men make it, but most are eaten by the dragon.
Recent Comments