It Takes Two to Gossip
Maybe I should have been a lawyer. I tend to think of wrongdoing in a systematic manner and assign measurable degrees of blame. Criminal punishment theory. For example, the severity of a crime might be modulated by intent, premeditation, accomplices and objects used, and the victim. That’s why premeditated murder is more severe than accidental manslaughter. The whole thing about MADD a few decades ago was to make drunk driving a worse offense. Their argument was that if you choose to drink and drive (increasing the risk to yourself, your passengers, and other motorists), you’ve made a premeditated decision. Welcome to your new jail cell.
I’ve always thought of gossip in the same way. The seriousness of the crime depends on various factors:
- Damage - Example: telling your parents about a fellow churchgoer’s past drug addiction vs. telling his fiancee’s parents.
- Intent - Example: telling his fiancee’s parents because of jealousy vs. concern for the fiancee. (Yeah, that’s arguable.)
- Premeditation - Example: rehearsing the story to make him look as bad as possible. “He borrowed money from me, spent it on drugs, and never paid me back!”
- Victim - Example: he never had the drug habit; you were making up the whole thing.
So let’s say I was jealous of him and wanted to screw up his relationship by carrying out this nefarious plan. After I tell the parents, they are predictably upset and run off to lecture the daughter, resulting in a big fight. Who’s to blame?
Naturally, I am. But some of the blame rests with the listener! In the example above, the parents should have stopped me during my story and asked if I’d tried to resolve it with him or brought him up before a pastor. If I said no, they should have refused to listen. It would have saved them a lot of grief. Instead, their blind acceptance of an unsubstantiated accusation validated my approach and rewarded my crime.
We are too quick to believe and too slow to confront each other to stop gossip at its root. I’ve been guilty of that many times myself; my approach to conflict resolution has been to hear out the two sides separately and then negotiate an agreement or compromise. Now I believe that only allows people to vent without encouraging them to do the real work of resolving the dispute themselves. You can’t help people by doing their homework.
Recent Comments